There was a time in my life when I believed healing meant finding the right answers.

The right spiritual path.

The right understanding of God.

The right philosophy.

The right psychological framework.

The right explanation for consciousness.

The right community.

If I could just discover the truth—completely and finally—I imagined I would feel at peace.

Looking back, I don't think I was simply searching for truth.

I think I was searching for safety.

That realization has changed the way I think about healing, spirituality, and even disagreement itself.

Today, I'm much less interested in convincing people that my perspective is the right one. Instead, I'm deeply curious about why we hold the beliefs we do, why it's so difficult to question them, and what happens inside us when those beliefs are challenged.

Because I no longer believe beliefs are only intellectual.

I think they're profoundly relational.

A Childhood Question That Never Left Me

Some of my earliest spiritual memories are from growing up Catholic.

When I was around eight years old, I wanted to become a priest.

Not because I wanted authority.

Not because I wanted recognition.

I was captivated by something much simpler.

I loved the idea of sitting with people as they wrestled with life's deepest questions.

Questions about love.

Suffering.

Meaning.

God.

Forgiveness.

Healing.

I imagined spending my life helping people navigate the mysteries of being human.

Then I was told something that confused me deeply.

I couldn't become a priest because I was a girl.

As a child, I couldn't make sense of it.

How could something centered on love, service, and the sacred be unavailable because of something I hadn't chosen?

That moment planted a question inside me that has stayed with me for decades:

Who decides whose spiritual experiences matter?

I didn't realize it then, but that question would shape much of my life.

When My Own Spiritual Experience Was Questioned

Years later, another experience challenged me in an entirely different way.

In 2008, I experienced what I understood to be a profound spiritual awakening.

At the same time, my life became deeply destabilized.

Old trauma memories emerged.

Questions about God, consciousness, healing, and identity flooded my awareness.

Everything I thought I knew seemed to unravel.

Eventually, my experience was diagnosed as psychosis.

That diagnosis was both painful and necessary. It helped me receive care during an incredibly difficult period of my life. At the same time, it also left me wrestling with questions that couldn't be answered by a diagnosis alone.

Was every spiritual experience simply illness?

Was every mystical experience unquestionably true?

Could both spirituality and psychology have something important to teach us?

I eventually realized I didn't have to choose between blind belief and total rejection.

Instead, I could cultivate something different.

Curiosity.

Grounded curiosity.

That shift became foundational to both my personal healing and my work as a therapist.

We Don't Encounter Ideas as Blank Slates

One of the biggest insights I've gained is this:

We don't engage with beliefs as purely rational beings.

We engage with them as human beings whose nervous systems have been shaped by relationships, culture, trauma, identity, and belonging.

Every one of us carries experiences that influence how we interpret the world.

Our families.

Our religious communities.

Our education.

Our culture.

Our friendships.

Our losses.

Our fears.

Our hopes.

These experiences don't simply influence what we believe.

They influence what feels safe to believe.

That distinction matters.

Beliefs Often Meet Emotional Needs

When we think about beliefs, we often assume people hold them because they've carefully evaluated all the available evidence.

Sometimes that's true.

But often, beliefs also serve emotional functions.

They can help us:

Feel safe.

Create meaning.

Reduce uncertainty.

Experience belonging.

Maintain identity.

Stay connected to a community.

Organize overwhelming experiences.

This doesn't make beliefs false.

It makes them human.

When we understand this, it becomes easier to approach disagreement with compassion rather than judgment.

Why Questioning Beliefs Feels So Threatening

If beliefs are connected to identity and belonging, then questioning them is rarely just an intellectual exercise.

Sometimes questioning a belief feels like questioning:

Who am I?

Where do I belong?

Can I trust myself?

Will people still accept me?

Will my community reject me?

Will life still make sense?

No wonder it feels difficult.

Our nervous systems aren't simply evaluating ideas.

They're evaluating safety.

What Happens Inside the Nervous System

One of the most fascinating things I've learned through neuroscience is that our brains constantly monitor for safety and threat.

When we feel emotionally secure, curiosity expands.

We become more flexible.

We can consider multiple perspectives.

We tolerate ambiguity.

But when we feel threatened, something very different happens.

Protection takes over.

Curiosity narrows.

Certainty becomes comforting.

We become more likely to defend our existing beliefs.

Not because we're irrational.

But because our nervous systems are trying to restore stability.

This happens across every belief system.

Religious.

Political.

Scientific.

Psychological.

Spiritual.

None of us are immune.

Protection Looks Different for Different People

Not everyone protects themselves the same way.

Some people become argumentative.

Some withdraw.

Some become highly intellectual.

Some seek reassurance.

Some immediately search for people who agree with them.

Some become emotionally overwhelmed.

Others become emotionally detached.

These aren't signs that one person is healthier than another.

They're different nervous systems attempting to regulate in different ways.

When I recognize this, I find it much easier to approach both myself and others with compassion.

Curiosity Shrinks When Protection Grows

One pattern I've noticed repeatedly—in therapy, in relationships, and within myself—is that curiosity becomes much harder when we're emotionally activated.

When I feel my identity is threatened...

I want certainty.

When I feel misunderstood...

I want to defend myself.

When I feel alone...

I want to find people who agree with me.

None of those impulses make me a bad person.

They make me human.

The important question isn't whether those protective impulses arise.

The question is whether I become aware of them.

Awareness creates choice.

Healing Isn't Replacing One Belief With Another

Many people assume healing means exchanging "wrong beliefs" for "right beliefs."

I don't think it's that simple.

Often healing begins somewhere much deeper.

It begins when we notice what is happening inside us while we believe.

Instead of asking only,

"Is this belief true?"

We might also ask,

"What happens inside me when this belief is challenged?"

"What need might this belief be meeting?"

"What am I afraid would happen if I questioned it?"

"What does my nervous system experience as being at stake?"

Those questions often reveal far more than arguments ever could.

The Space That Changes Everything

One of the most beautiful changes I've witnessed in both myself and the people I work with isn't that they become less emotional.

It's that they develop more space.

More space between emotion and reaction.

More space between identity and defensiveness.

More space between uncertainty and panic.

More space between disagreement and disconnection.

Within that space, something remarkable becomes possible.

People remain passionate.

But they're less controlled by passion.

They remain committed to their values.

But they're less threatened by different perspectives.

They remain spiritually engaged.

But they're more comfortable with mystery.

Humility Is Not the Opposite of Conviction

For a long time, I thought certainty demonstrated strength.

Today, I increasingly think humility requires even greater courage.

Humility doesn't mean abandoning conviction.

It means holding our convictions while remaining open to learning.

It means recognizing that every human being—including ourselves—perceives reality through the lens of their own experiences.

It means remembering that our understanding can continue evolving throughout our lives.

The more I study psychology, neuroscience, spirituality, and trauma, the more I appreciate how much remains mysterious.

Oddly enough, that mystery no longer frightens me.

It invites me into deeper curiosity.

Ideas Carry Responsibility

One of the reasons this matters so deeply to me is because ideas shape lives.

The beliefs we teach influence how people relate to themselves.

How parents raise children.

How communities include or exclude.

How partners communicate.

How societies define compassion.

As a therapist, teacher, and spiritual mentor, I don't see my role as convincing people to adopt my worldview.

I see it as creating conversations that help people become more aware of how they relate to their beliefs.

I continually ask myself:

• Does this increase clarity?
• Does this deepen compassion?
• Does this support agency?
• Does this encourage people to trust themselves more deeply?
• Or does it unintentionally encourage dependence on external authority?

These questions keep me grounded.

And I hope they always will.

A Different Relationship With Truth

Perhaps the greatest change in my own life is this:

I no longer believe healing means becoming certain.

I believe healing means becoming secure enough that uncertainty no longer feels like a threat.

I can question my beliefs without losing myself.

I can change my mind without losing my identity.

I can remain deeply committed to my values while honoring the humanity of people who see the world differently.

That doesn't mean all ideas are equally helpful or equally true.

Discernment still matters.

Accountability still matters.

Evidence still matters.

But I've discovered that discernment becomes wiser when it's guided by curiosity rather than fear.

An Invitation Into Curiosity

I don't offer these reflections because I have finally arrived at the truth.

I offer them because I've learned that healing isn't about reaching a destination where every question disappears.

It's about developing the capacity to stay in relationship—with ourselves, with one another, and with life's deepest mysteries—even when certainty remains out of reach.

So I'd like to leave you with a few questions that continue to shape my own journey:

• What happens inside your body when one of your deeply held beliefs is challenged?
• Do you notice yourself becoming curious, defensive, withdrawn, or certain?
• What might your nervous system be trying to protect?
• Can you remain connected to yourself even while exploring ideas that stretch your understanding?
• And what if wisdom isn't found in never questioning—but in learning how to question with enough humility that love, curiosity, and connection remain possible?

I don't know that any of us will ever finish answering those questions.

And perhaps that's exactly the point.

Continue the Conversation

If this reflection resonated with you, I'd love to hear your thoughts. How has your relationship with your beliefs changed over time? Have you discovered that questioning long-held assumptions can deepen—not weaken—your sense of self?

If you'd like to explore these themes further, my book The Divine Within: Healing Ourselves to Heal the World examines how spirituality, psychology, neuroscience, and compassionate self-awareness can help us cultivate a healthier relationship with truth, uncertainty, and ourselves.

You can also learn more about my coaching, educational resources, and community through Blossoming Heart Wellness.

My hope is not that we all believe the same things. It's that we become secure enough within ourselves to explore life's deepest questions with humility, discernment, and compassion—recognizing that growth is often found not in clinging to certainty, but in remaining open to learning while staying deeply rooted in our shared humanity.

‍